Rehearsing the Real
In times of growing instability, the concept of “rehearsing the Real” offers a useful frame for understanding certain postures emerging from New Monastic and Non-Church spaces. The Real—borrowing from Lacanian psychoanalysis—refers not to objective reality, but to that which ruptures it: the unbearable, the unassimilable, the thing that cannot be symbolized. If the Symbolic Order represents the structured, nameable world we live within, the Real is what shatters it. Increasingly, fractures in contemporary life suggest that rehearsals of the Real are already underway.
For some, particularly in the U.S., civil disobedience and protest have functioned as rehearsals for deeper systemic ruptures. These actions have traditionally been viewed as part of the democratic process—symbolic gestures that test the boundaries of state power and public conscience. But as those boundaries harden, and consequences become more severe, such rehearsals begin to resemble early encounters with a more destabilizing reality: the Real no longer at a distance but encroaching.
In contrast, expressions of contemplative spirituality in the UK—especially within New Monasticism—have rehearsed the Real in, more interior ways. Rhythms of silence, prayer, and shared vulnerability were not designed as solutions, but as ways of staying present to disintegration. They offered a slow exposure to loss, meaninglessness, and uncertainty, before those forces took material form in wider social or political collapse.
But we must be cautious. To say these communities have “rehearsed the Real” is not to suggest they are prepared for it. The Real, by definition, cannot be mastered or anticipated. One does not practice for a rupture; one only cultivates the capacity to remain present in its aftermath. If there is any value in these so-called rehearsals, it lies in their refusal to cling to illusion—whether theological, institutional, or ideological.
The Non-Church, for example, is sometimes portrayed as uniquely suited to life beyond belief as we have known it, yet it too must resist the temptation to become a container for what cannot be contained. A posture of doubt is not inherently virtuous. It can calcify just as easily as certainty. The goal is not to replace one orthodoxy with another, but to remain radically open to what the Real exposes—about power, about self-deception, and about our desperate strategies for holding the world together.
The danger in our time is not that people will be unprepared for the Real—it is that they will mistake their rehearsals for the event itself. That they will assume their practices, however meaningful, are sufficient defence’s. But when the rupture comes—and it always does—it will not consult our structures of meaning, nor respect our preparations.
What contemplative and activist communities may offer, then, is not foresight but posture—a way of anticipating something that none of us want to see happen or experience.
See:
Attention as the Spiritual Discipline of the Age | Presence in the Age of AI
This essay seves as part of the ‘ New Monasticism’ material for this site.
