Introduction
New Monasticism is not a uniform movement but a constellation of responses to the crisis of institutional Christianity and the search for a lived, embodied faith. While sharing common inspiration in Dietrich Bonhoeffer’s vision of “a new type of monasticism,” the UK and USA expressions evolved along markedly different lines.
Each movement emerged from its own social, theological, and historical context—New Monasticism UK from the ruins of Christendom in a post-Christian society, and New Monastics USA from within the tensions of consumer Christianity, urban poverty, and political unrest.
This article explores how these two expressions both converge and diverge—culturally, spiritually, and theologically.
New Monasticism (UK)
- Principal Players: John Skinner, Linda Skinner, Andy Raine
- Influences: The Perverse Core of Jesus Teaching Dietrich Bonhoeffer, Desert Fathers and Mothers, Celtic Monasticism,
- Ethos: Unintentional community, dispersed spirituality, faith and doubt held in tension
- Approach: Contemplative rhythms, simplicity, hospitality, and cultural exile
Emerging in the early 1980s, the Northumbria Community was born out of dislocation, trauma, and a deep sense of ecclesial homelessness. Drawing on ancient monastic sources—particularly the Desert Fathers and Celtic spirituality—it sought to recover a way of living that could sustain faith during cultural collapse.
Rather than founding monasteries in the traditional sense, the community created dispersed patterns of life held together by shared commitments—Availability to God and others, and Vulnerability in relationship. It was less about rebuilding the Church than surviving its ruins with integrity.
Faith and doubt were not polarities to be resolved but held together as part of the spiritual landscape. This expression of monasticism is shaped more by presence than programs, and by the rhythm of the daily office rather than the call to activism. It offers a kind of internal exile—an alternative spiritual path in a post-Christian landscape.
New Monastics (USA)
- Principal Players: Shane Claiborne, Jonathan Wilson-Hartgrove
- Influences: Sermon on the Mount Bonhoeffer, Francis of Assisi, the Anabaptist tradition, Catholic Worker Movement
- Ethos: Intentional community, radical hospitality, nonviolence, and resistance to empire
- Approach: Communal living, social action, prophetic witness
Emerging at the end of the 1990’s New Monastics USA arose from frustration with consumer-driven evangelicalism and the perceived disconnect between church rhetoric and Jesus’ call to justice. This movement planted itself in neglected neighbourhoods, aiming to embody the radical implications of the Sermon on the Mount.
Unlike the Northumbria Community’s contemplative posture, New Monastics lean into confrontation with systemic injustice. Their emphasis is on economic sharing, solidarity with the poor, and resistance to empire—inspired by historical movements that embodied Christian nonconformity.
Their theological framework tends to be more activist and reformist. Doubt exists, but it is often subordinated to the imperatives of action and the urgency of justice.
Comparison Table
| Theme | New Monasticism (UK) | New Monastics (USA) |
| Origins | John & Linda Skinner, Andy Raine (1980s) | Shane Claiborne, Jonathan Wilson-Hartgrove (2000s) |
| Theological Roots | The Perverse Core of Jesus Teaching Bonhoeffer, Celtic Monasticism, Desert Fathers, | Sermon on the Mount Bonhoeffer, Anabaptists, Franciscans, Catholic Worker Movement |
| Community Form | Dispersed, Rule of Life, “Alone Together” | Intentional communities, shared life |
| Spiritual Emphasis | Prayer, silence, daily rhythms | Radical hospitality, nonviolence, activism |
| View of Doubt | Embraced as part of the journey | Present, but not central |
| Engagement with the World | Through presence, hospitality, questioning | Through protest, community organizing, resistance |
Conclusion: A Shared Call
Both expressions of New Monasticism are deeply rooted in the perverse core of Jesus’ teaching—particularly the disruptive ethics of the Sermon on the Mount. Each challenges the Church’s complicity with power, its nostalgia for institutional security, and its fear of uncertainty.
- New Monasticism UK offers a contemplative, quiet resistance—living gently in a fractured world, bearing witness to a deeper rhythm.
- New Monastics USA offers an embodied confrontation—standing alongside the oppressed, confronting empire, and making visible the cost of discipleship.
Each represents a genuine response to The Event—a theological, cultural, and political rupture that has exposed the inadequacy of traditional religion. And each, in its own way, answers Bonhoeffer’s call for “a new type of monasticism” not as a nostalgic return to cloistered religion, but as an imaginative and faithful response to a world going through major crisis and changes.
See:
This essay seves as part of the ‘ New Monasticism’ material for this site.
