We Don’t Believe in God, but We Are Not Atheists

A Faith That Refuses to Settle

We live in the wreckage of certainty. The old binaries—faith or doubt, believer or atheist, churchgoer or secular—no longer hold. Something has fractured, and we find ourselves in the space between.

Some of us left the church because it could no longer contain our questions. Others remain on the edges, unable to fully commit but unwilling to walk away. We do not believe in God—not in the way we were taught—but we are not atheists. We are still drawn to something deeper than reason, beyond deconstruction, outside the walls of doctrine and disbelief alike.

This is the strange space of A/Theism—not the rejection of faith, but faith that refuses to be pinned down. It is the common ground where New Monasticism and the Non-Church movement meet—not in shared certainty, but in shared longing.

God After the Death of God

Nietzsche’s Death of God was not just a statement of atheism—it was a prophetic warning. When the foundations of belief collapse, what fills the void? Nationalism? Consumerism? Political ideology disguised as faith? In the vacuum left behind, we see both the rise of hyperreality—where truth is manufactured and faith becomes performance—and the hijacking of religion by power, where God is invoked not to liberate, but to control.

For some, the answer is to double down on certainty—to retreat into fundamentalism, to rebuild the old walls even as they crumble. For others, it is to walk away entirely—to abandon faith and embrace the cold clarity of atheism.

But what if there is another way?

What if, instead of running toward certainty—either religious or secular—we stay in the uncertainty itself? Not to reject God, but to refuse every false image of God. Not to abandon faith, but to strip it of illusion.

The Perverse Core of Jesus’ Teaching: A/Theism in Practice

If the Non-Church movement is about faith beyond institutions, and New Monasticism is about faith beyond performance, then A/Theism is about faith beyond belief itself.

Jesus was not a system-builder. He did not leave behind a structure, a clear theological model, or an institutional blueprint. What he left was rupture—a tearing apart of power, morality, and even religion itself. His teachings in the Sermon on the Mount push morality beyond its limits, exposing its contradictions. His actions disrupt the structures of temple and empire alike. His crucifixion is the ultimate loss—the collapse of every messianic expectation, every certainty, every illusion.

This is why Žižek, Rollins, and Caputo resonate in this space. They do not ask, “Do you believe in God?” but instead, “What do you do when everything collapses?” They recognize that Christianity is not about holding onto God, but about letting go of the false gods we’ve created.

To say we don’t believe in God, but we are not atheists is to say:
🔹 We refuse the God of empire, but we are still drawn to what Jesus revealed.
🔹 We do not pray to an interventionist deity, yet we still experience moments of deep presence.
🔹 We cannot claim certainty, yet we are not content with nothingness.
🔹 We reject religious institutions, yet we crave a way to live faith honestly, beyond the performance of belief.

New Monasticism & The Non-Church: Coming Together in a Time of Crisis

New Monasticism seeks to recover what was lost—not by rebuilding the church, but by reclaiming rhythms of contemplation, hospitality, and resistance. The Non-Church movement, by contrast, is about staying in the collapse itself, refusing to replace one certainty with another.

But both recognize that faith cannot be contained within institutions. Both reject the commodification of belief, the spectacle of religion, and the easy answers of both church and secularism. Both recognize that we must learn to live in the Desert of the Real—a world where truth is distorted, faith is politicized, and meaning is harder to grasp than ever.

We do not need a new church.
We do not need another ideology.
We need a space where faith and doubt can exist together, where silence is not emptiness, and where the absence of certainty does not mean the absence of God.

The Invitation: To Live the Question

So what does it mean to believe without belief? To have faith beyond certainty?

It means we hold no dogma, but deep conviction.
It means we seek something real, even if we can never name it.
It means we remain open—radically open—to grace, mystery, and the unknown.

To say we don’t believe in God, but we are not atheists is to say:

We are still here.
Still searching.
Still haunted by something we cannot define.

And maybe—just maybe—that is enough.

Welcome to the tension. Welcome to the conversation.

See:

Non-Church A space beyond belief and unbelief

 

 

 

This essay seves as part of the ‘ Non-Church’ material for this site.